Community Forum, Dundee - May 2020

On 11 May Deputy Governor Sam Woods hosted our first virtual Community Forum with third sector representatives from Dundee. This was the second meeting with the Dundee representatives and his reflections are below.

This year’s Community Forum event for Dundee was held under considerably different circumstances from last year’s. I was sorry not to be able to be there in person, in the V&A’s cool new building which is where we met a year ago.* 

Thanks to the wonders of modern technology, however, I did get the chance to catch up with the leaders of Dundee’s charities and listen to their take on the current unprecedented situation. The Covid situation makes these events even more important than they always are. 

When I was actually in Dundee last year, I visited some absolutely inspirational charities. These included the Main Street Café, a community initiative for people struggling to afford food, and the Hot Chocolate Trust, which supports the city’s young people to develop their own opportunities. I was gratified to be able to identify the Leicester metalcore band whose poster was on the wall at the Trust, rather to the bemusement of the teenagers showing me around! 

It was painfully obvious across these visits how up until recently some people in Dundee were still feeling the effects of the financial crisis of 2008 – with food banks, in-work poverty and fuel poverty among the issues being dealt with by the city’s charitable organisations. The team and I felt we should re-visit these issues as we face another crisis in real-time. 

Dundee has been hit hard by Covid-19. It has one of the highest death rates in Scotland. Unsurprisingly therefore the challenges faced by the organisations I spoke to are particularly acute at this time. 

During the meeting I had with charities I heard that the lockdown, necessary though it is,  has exacerbated some problems and inequalities that were already serious before the pandemic hit. Worryingly but unsurprisingly, severe mental health difficulties in vulnerable young people are worsening in this stressful time – and uncertainty about both the near and long-term future is adding to this. 

Concerns were expressed about the employment situation in Dundee – in particular the numbers of people who were in precarious forms of employment before the pandemic and are now unable to work, but who are also not receiving support through the government’s furlough scheme. There was a feeling that social inequality is widening, and heightened worries about whether the population of Dundee will be able to upskill as needed through and after the crisis.

The thing that strikes you at these sorts of meetings is really just the most obvious thing: the level of unemployment has been low in recent times, but that doesn’t mean the system is working well for everyone. We mustn’t let healthy aggregate statistics allow us to become complacent (here I am channelling my inner Andy Haldane – though Andy makes this point much more powerfully!). And the Covid crisis is likely to hit both the aggregate and the local in nasty ways.

I’m worried that if you’re reading this you may have found is a slightly depressing blog! Well, it is a tough situation. But on the other side of the coin, there are many incredibly energetic and innovative people working very hard in the third sector in Dundee in order to cushion the blow for others. I found it interesting to reflect on the comparison with our own role: we’re working deep in the plumbing, in a way that affects the entire economy in a very significant way. Third sector colleagues in Dundee have a similar aim, but are working way downstream of us. All strength to their arm!

I would like to thank Mary Duffy at the Juniper Trust for helping us bring such an interesting group together again, to everyone who spared the time to join the meeting and talk to us, and to our Scotland Agency for doing a great job arranging and then hosting the meeting.

*Image taken at previous Community Forum at the V&A in Dundee in April 2019.

This page was last updated 31 January 2023